Mount Saint Helens Carbon Dating Error
Contents |
is properly acknowledged and the material is not altered, edited or sold. INTRODUCTION Because radiometric dating utterly refutes their biblical interpretations, young-Earth creationists (YECs) are desperate to undermine the reality of these methods. As part of their efforts, excess argon within mineral concentrates from the new dacite lava dome at mount st helens volcano YEC Dr. Steve Austin and his associates at the Institute for Creation 'Research' (ICR) collected mount st helens rock layers a dacite sample from Mt. St. Helens, Washington State, USA, which probably erupted in 1986 AD. Austin et al. then ineffectively separated
Radiometric Dating Flaws
the sample into several mineral and glass 'fractions', submitted the dacite and its 'fractions' for potassium 40-argon 40 (K-Ar) dating, and subsequently used the bogus results to inappropriately attack the K-Ar method. Austin's conclusions on this project
Dr. Steve Austin
are summarized at the ICR website. The 'research' efforts of Austin and his colleagues and their 'expertise' in radiometric dating have been widely criticized, including by Joe Meert (also here), Karen Bartelt and company and myself at No Answers in Genesis and in my web debate with Dr. David Plaisted at Tim Thompson's 'A Radiometric Dating Resource List' (also here). Austin rarely responds to his critics. However, non-geologist YECs, such as MD Keith Swenson at dr steve austin geologist Is the Lava Dome at Mt. St. Helens Really a Million Years Old? and at the Answers in Genesis' website, have attempted to defend Austin's work. Although Swenson accompanied Austin on a trip to Mt. St. Helens, there is no indication from his writings that Swenson is familiar with igneous petrology, geochronology or even geology in general. AUSTIN FAILED TO PROPERLY USE THE K-Ar METHOD Considering that the half-life of potassium-40 (40K) is fairly long (1,250 million years, McDougall and Harrison, 1999, p. 9), the K-Ar method cannot be used to date samples that are much younger than 6,000 years old (Dalrymple, 1991, p. 93). A few thousand years are not enough time for 40Ar to accumulate in a sample at high enough concentrations to be detected and quantified. Furthermore, many geochronology laboratories do not have the expensive state-of-the-art equipment to accurately measure argon in samples that are only a few million years old. Specifically, the laboratory personnel that performed the K-Ar dating for Austin et al. Specifically, personnel at Geochron Laboratories of Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA,performed the K-Ar dating for Austin et al.This laboratory no longer performs K-Ardating.However, when theydid, their websiteclearly stated in a footnote that their equipment could notaccurately date rocks that are younger than about 2 million years old ("We cannot analyze samples expected to be younger than 2 M.Y.";
daily devotional to strengthen and encourage the Christian witnessToday's DevotionalPast DevotionalsFree SubscriptionCreation Science Update Timely news related to creation
Radiometric Dating Accuracy
and evolutionThis Week's ArticlesPast ArticlesFree Mobile AppTechnical Papers In-depth is carbon dating accurate peer-reviewed scientific articlesPast ArticlesLatest ArticlesBooks Books for developing a sound and fruitful Christian worldviewGuide to john morris the Human BodyGuide to SeriesCreation Basics & BeyondDinosaurs and the BibleMore Books...DVDs and Videos Get equipped with defensible answers to the most controversial questions of http://www.noanswersingenesis.org.au/mt_st_helens_dacite_kh.htm faith and scienceMade in His ImageUnlocking the Mysteries of GenesisDinosaurs and ManICR WebcastThat's a FactMore Videos...ResourcesPhysical Sciences Our universe and our planet were created for lifeAstronomy Math and LogicPhysics Radiometric DatingEarth Sciences The global record shows recent creation and catastropheAge of the Earth Climate Change DinosaursFossil Record Ice AgeNoah's Ark http://www.icr.org/article/a-30-years-later-lessons-mount-st-helens/ and FloodOceansLife Sciences The miraculous complexity of life is rich in information and precise in structureBotanyGeneticsHuman BodyMicrobiologyOrigin of LifeProblems with EvolutionZoologyEvidence for Creation Discover the many lines of evidence that confirm biblical truthEvidence for GodEvidence for TruthEvidence from NatureEvidence from ScienceEvidence from ScriptureSchool of Biblical Apologetics Training in biblical education and apologetics at the certificate, undergraduate, and graduate levelsCompare ProgramsApologetics ArticlesApologetics Q&AChristian EducationCalendarTeach All ThingsICR StoreEventsUpcoming ICR EventsOur SpeakersHow to Host an EventSupport ICRDonate NowDonate MonthlyPlanned Giving 30 Years Later, the Lessons from Mount St. Helens by Brian Thomas, M.S. * Evidence for Creation › Evidence from Science › Evidence from the Earth Sciences › Geological Processes Were Catastrophic › Global Catastrophic Model On May 18, 1980, a tremendous landslide on the northern side of Mount St. Helens in Washington state uncapped a violent volcanic eruption, completely altering the surrounding landscape. It is the most studied volcano
MSN Index Bing NBCNews.com sites & shows: TODAY Nightly News Meet the Press Dateline Morning Joe Hardball Ed Maddow The Last Word msnbc Home US World Politics Business Sports Entertainment Health Tech Science Travel Local Weather Evolution on NBCNews.com http://www.nbcnews.com/id/7013405/ns/technology_and_science-science/t/stirring-mount/ Search Advertise The stirring on the mount St. Helens used in drive to prove biblical creation with science Below: x Jump to discuss comments below discuss x Next story in Evolution King rat and the brilliant squibbon related https://ageofrocks.org/2015/03/09/a-creationists-understanding-of-radiocarbon-dating/ Advertise James Cheng / MSNBC.com Lloyd Anderson, far right, takes home-schooled children on a tour of the land around Mount St. Helens, pointing out geologic structures formed by the volcano's eruption in 1980 that young-Earth creationists say support carbon dating their beliefs. By M. Alex Johnson Reporter msnbc.com updated 5/2/2005 6:00:58 PM ET 2005-05-02T22:00:58 Print Font: + - SILVERLAKE, Wash.-- “Look! You can see the mountain!” Lloyd Anderson springs ahead of the small group of visitors he has been leading through Gifford Pinchot National Forest. Reaching a small observational clearing, he sweeps his arm toward the horizon and bounces with excitement as he waits for the group — Forest Carnine, a cattle rancher from Angora, mount st helens Neb.; his wife, Dorothy; their daughter-in-law, Ingrid Carnine of Boring, Ore.; and her two young sons — to catch up. It is one of those rare days when the weather in southwest Washington clears so you can see Mount St. Helens, which rises behind Anderson and his joyous grin. The snow-capped volcano dazzles against a crystal blue sky, its peak obliterated 25 years ago in an eruption that left it looking like a dish of vanilla ice cream whose top has been scooped off by an eager child. Lloyd Anderson still gets revved up by the mountain. He is 69 and hard of hearing, but when he gets rolling in the booming cadences of the nondenominational minister he was until 1999, the years fall away and the words tumble out with the message he has committed his retirement to bringing forth. Which is: The Earth is only a few thousand years old, and what happened here in 1980 proves it. In the beginning ... Anderson and his wife, Doris, are the founders of the Mount St. Helens Creation Information Center and curators of the 7 Wonders Creation Museum. They represent a third wave of modern biblical creationist thinking, one that says hard-core science proves the Genesis account of creation. Mainstream scientists say that because it can sound plausible to non-specialists, it could be a partic