Error Bars Overlap Means
Contents |
in a publication or presentation, you may be tempted to draw conclusions about the statistical significance of differences between group means by looking at whether the error bars overlap. what does it mean if error bars overlap Let's look at two contrasting examples. What can you conclude when standard error
What Does It Mean When Standard Error Bars Overlap
bars do not overlap? When standard error (SE) bars do not overlap, you cannot be sure that the if error bars overlap are they significant difference between two means is statistically significant. Even though the error bars do not overlap in experiment 1, the difference is not statistically significant (P=0.09 by unpaired t test). This is if error bars overlap is there a significant difference also true when you compare proportions with a chi-square test. What can you conclude when standard error bars do overlap? No surprises here. When SE bars overlap, (as in experiment 2) you can be sure the difference between the two means is not statistically significant (P>0.05). What if you are comparing more than two groups? Post tests following one-way ANOVA account
How To Interpret Error Bars
for multiple comparisons, so they yield higher P values than t tests comparing just two groups. So the same rules apply. If two SE error bars overlap, you can be sure that a post test comparing those two groups will find no statistical significance. However if two SE error bars do not overlap, you can't tell whether a post test will, or will not, find a statistically significant difference. What if the error bars do not represent the SEM? Error bars that represent the 95% confidence interval (CI) of a mean are wider than SE error bars -- about twice as wide with large sample sizes and even wider with small sample sizes. If 95% CI error bars do not overlap, you can be sure the difference is statistically significant (P < 0.05). However, the converse is not true--you may or may not have statistical significance when the 95% confidence intervals overlap. Some graphs and tables show the mean with the standard deviation (SD) rather than the SEM. The SD quantifies variability, but does not account for sample size. To assess statistical sign
Graphpad.com FAQs Find ANY word Find ALL words Find EXACT phrase What you can conclude when two error bars overlap (or don't)? FAQ# 1362 Last Modified 22-April-2010 It is tempting to look at whether two error large error bars bars overlap or not, and try to reach a conclusion about whether the difference sem error bars between means is statistically significant. Resist that temptation (Lanzante, 2005)! SD error bars SD error bars quantify the scatter among the
Error Bars 95 Confidence Interval Excel
values. Looking at whether the error bars overlap lets you compare the difference between the mean with the amount of scatter within the groups. But the t test also takes into account sample size. https://egret.psychol.cam.ac.uk/statistics/local_copies_of_sources_Cardinal_and_Aitken_ANOVA/errorbars.htm If the samples were larger with the same means and same standard deviations, the P value would be much smaller. If the samples were smaller with the same means and same standard deviations, the P value would be larger. When the difference between two means is statistically significant (P < 0.05), the two SD error bars may or may not overlap. Likewise, when the difference between two means http://www.graphpad.com/support/faqid/1362/ is not statistically significant (P > 0.05), the two SD error bars may or may not overlap. Knowing whether SD error bars overlap or not does not let you conclude whether difference between the means is statistically significant or not. SEM error bars SEM error bars quantify how precisely you know the mean, taking into account both the SD and sample size. Looking at whether the error bars overlap, therefore, lets you compare the difference between the mean with the precision of those means. This sounds promising. But in fact, you don’t learn much by looking at whether SEM error bars overlap. By taking into account sample size and considering how far apart two error bars are, Cumming (2007) came up with some rules for deciding when a difference is significant or not. But these rules are hard to remember and apply. Here is a simpler rule: If two SEM error bars do overlap, and the sample sizes are equal or nearly equal, then you know that the P value is (much) greater than 0.05, so the difference is not statistically significant. The opposite rule does not apply. If two SEM error bars do not overlap, the P value could be less than 0.
CatservEvolutionBlogGreg Laden's BlogLife LinesPage 3.14PharyngulaRespectful InsolenceSignificant Figures by Peter GleickStarts With A BangStoatThe Pump HandleThe Weizmann http://scienceblogs.com/cognitivedaily/2008/07/31/most-researchers-dont-understa-1/ WaveUncertain PrinciplesUSA Science and Engineering Festival: The BlogWorld's Fair2010 World Science Festival BlogA Blog Around The ClockAdventures in Ethics and ScienceA Good PoopAll of My Faults Are Stress RelatedAngry ToxicologistApplied StatisticsArt of Science LearningA Vote For ScienceBasic Concepts in SciencebioephemeraBlogging error bars the OriginBrookhaven Bits & BytesBuilt on FactsChaotic UtopiaChristina's LIS RantClass MCognitive DailyCommon KnowledgeCulture DishDean's CornerDeep Sea NewsDeveloping IntelligenceDispatches from the Creation WarsDot PhysicsDr. Joan Bushwell's Chimpanzee RefugeEffect MeasureEruptionsevolgenEvolution for EveryoneEvolving ThoughtsFraming ScienceGalactic InteractionsGene ExpressionGenetic FutureGood Math, Bad MathGreen GabbroGuilty PlanetIntegrity of error bars overlap ScienceIntel ISEFLaelapsLife at the SETI InstituteLive from ESOF 2014Living the Scientific Life (Scientist, Interrupted)Mike the Mad BiologistMixing MemoryMolecule of the DayMyrmecosNeuron CultureNeuronticNeurophilosophyNeurotopiaNot Exactly Rocket ScienceObesity PanaceaObservations of a NerdOf Two MindsOmni BrainOn Becoming a Domestic and Laboratory GoddessOscillatorPhoto SynthesisPure PedantryRetrospectacle: A Neuroscience BlogRevolutionary Minds Think TankScience + SocietyScience After SunclipseScience is CultureScienceOnline 2010: The BlogSciencePunkScience To LifeSciencewomenSeed/MoMA SalonSee Jane ComputeShifting BaselinesSignoutSpeakeasy ScienceSpeaking Science 2.0Stranger FruitSuperbugTerra SigillataTetrapod ZoologyThe Blogger SAT ChallengeThe Book of TrogoolThe Cheerful OncologistThe Corpus CallosumThe Examining Room of Dr. CharlesThe Frontal CortexThe IntersectionThe Island of DoubtThe LoomThe Primate DiariesThe Quantum PontiffThe Questionable AuthorityThe Rightful Place ProjectThe ScienceBlogs Book ClubThe Scientific ActivistThe Scientific IndianThe Thoughtful AnimalThe Voltage GateThoughts from KansasThus Spake ZuskaTomorrow's TableTranscription and TranslationUniverseWalt at RandomWe BeastiesWhite Coat UndergroundZooillog