Form Error Messages Usability
Contents |
& Navigation Analysis Usability Testing UX Strategy Consulting In-House Training Reports Articles About NN/G Overview People Why NN/g? Contact examples of good error messages News History Books Search Home Training Consulting Reports Articles About
Form Error Messages Design
NN/G Browse by Topic and Author Topics E-commerce Intranets Mobile & Tablet User Testing error messages best practices Web Usability See all topics… All Article Topics All Topics (hide) Accessibility Agile Analytics & Metrics Application Design B2B Websites Behavior Patterns Branding friendly error messages examples Collaboration Content Strategy Corporate Websites Design Patterns Design Process E-commerce Email Eyetracking Heuristic Evaluation Human Computer Interaction Ideation Information Architecture Interaction Design International Users Intranets Management Mobile & Tablet Navigation Non-Profit Websites Personas Persuasive Design Prototyping Psychology and UX Research Methods Search Social Media Strategy User Testing Visual
Error Message Ux
Design Web Usability Writing for the Web Young Users Author Jakob Nielsen Don Norman Bruce "Tog" Tognazzini See all authors… All Authors (hide) Aurora Bedford Raluca Budiu Susan Farrell Therese Fessenden Kim Flaherty Sarah Gibbons Page Laubheimer Angie Li Hoa Loranger Kate Meyer Jakob Nielsen Don Norman Kara Pernice Christian Rohrer Amy Schade Katie Sherwin Bruce "Tog" Tognazzini Kathryn Whitenton Kate Williamson Recent Articles Frequency & Recency of Site Visits: 2 Metrics for User Engagement International B2B Audiences: Top 5 Ways to Improve Your Site for Global Users Net Promoter Score: What a Customer-Relations Metric Can Tell You About Your User Experience 6 Tips for Successful Personalization 5 Information Architecture Warning Signs in Your Analytics Reports See all articles… Popular Articles Usability 101: Introduction to Usability Top 10 Mistakes in Web Design How Users Read on the Web F-Shaped Pattern
Start here for a quick overview of the site Help Center Detailed answers to any questions you might have Meta Discuss the workings and policies of this site About Us Learn more about Stack Overflow the company Business Learn more "error message" guidelines about hiring developers or posting ads with us User Experience Questions Tags Users Badges Unanswered Ask form error messages html Question _ User Experience Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for user experience researchers and experts. Join them; it only takes
Guidelines For Designing Effective Error Messages
a minute: Sign up Here's how it works: Anybody can ask a question Anybody can answer The best answers are voted up and rise to the top What is best practice for designing form error messages? up vote https://www.nngroup.com/articles/error-message-guidelines/ 136 down vote favorite 92 I've seen quite a lot of research on form design, but so far, I haven't come across any studies on error message design best practices. The only piece of advice seems to be that each error should clearly be associated with the invalid form field that it aims to correct. Has there been any research on this? I have some specific issues I'm trying to work through and would appreciate any insight or http://ux.stackexchange.com/questions/26173/what-is-best-practice-for-designing-form-error-messages resources. Error message location When you have live form validation, where should an error (or success) message appear in relation to the form element? Some options: To the right of the input download bmml source – Wireframes created with Balsamiq Mockups To the right of the label download bmml source Above the label download bmml source Below the label download bmml source Below the input download bmml source There are some thorny issues that also need to be taken into account regarding location: How are errors displayed for radio or checkbox groups? How wide is the error message? Is the error message multi-line? Error message visibility Besides location, I'm also interested in how the visibility of the error message affects its usability. Does it matter or is it strictly a aesthetic decision? Consider the following 3 options: download bmml source Edit: There have been some excellent points on accessibility in some of the answers so far, as well as some interesting examples. However, I really would like to see some data from actual studies, if possible. Also, none of the answers so far have really addressed the two questions I had above: Where should the error be located in relation to the input and label? How does the design and visibility of the error message itself affect its usability? Regarding the accessibility of the forms, it seems to me
Experience View 21 comments Outline In order to display error messages on forms, you need to consider the following four basic rules: The error message needs to be short http://www.nomensa.com/blog/2010/4-rules-displaying-error-messages-user-experience-perspective and meaningful The placement of the message needs to be associated with the https://medium.com/@andrew.burton/form-validation-best-practices-8e3bec7d0549 field The message style needs to be separated from the style of the field labels and instructions The style of the error field needs to be different than the normal field By combining these four rules, it is possible to provide the necessary information to users where they have made mistakes error message on filling in forms and how to rectify them quickly and easily. This will encourage and help users to continue with their journey on the site; reduce basket abandonment; increase site registrations; increase enquiries about an application form and so forth. Introduction A typical interaction with many websites is filling in forms. For example, if you are buying something online, you have to give form error messages your card details, delivery address and other personal information. By clever placement of labels, instructions to fill in a field and additional design elements can make a form less daunting and may result in fewer mistakes made (Jarrett, C. and Gaffney, G., 2008). However, I have seen that users make the same mistakes on forms again and again as these websites show error messages which are either not very clear to the user or because of their placement; users are unclear what messages relate to. This article focuses on how to provide error messages on forms from a user experience perspective. The message The error message needs to be clear, precise, short and punchy. Users should be able to immediately understand what ‘mistakes they have made’ and how to recover the error. This is fundamental and will have a huge impact if users can’t immediately understand what mistake they have made. One example of an unclear error message is on the Hotmail registration page where it asks for user’s ‘Birth year’. I remember using only two digits to represent a year before the year 2000. Well, the form does no
a long payment form online just to be rewarded with 76 error messages once you’ve pressed submit, annoying isn’t it, especially when it isn’t clear what errors you’ve committed, and where!We recently had a chance to re-look at this problem at uSwitch.com as part of our ongoing rebranding process, and as expected finding a unified system for form validation proved both problematic but rewarding. Through this article I will try to explain the specific problems we had and our approach to solving them, which in turn laid out a specific set of 10 rules that we used at uSwitch.com.Firstly, what is form validationForm validation is the process used by form dialogs to alert users of errors in their submissions. In recent times the usage of positive messaging in validation has grown which has helped to gamify the process of form inputs. In general terms their are two variants of validation implementation;Instant validation which occurs as the user is typing or selecting form elementsSame page reload validation which is used once a form has been submitted, before reloading the page with errors displayed.Our problemWe had a variety of form types and inputs across the site; checkboxes, radio buttons, multi-selects, password inputs et al which required different messaging regarding their validation, but, as we tried to unify the once divergent appearance of the site under one uSwitch branded banner we needed an all encompassing solution that worked on mobile, to desktop, in a variety of different situations.ProcessAs with all successful projects we started with research, internally and externally. With a quick audit of our site we realised we had compiled an elaborate array of validation elements, none of which were truly consistent, and some of which fail