Fate Vs. Human Error
Contents |
error that is passed off as "fate". When Romeo meets Juliet at Capulet's feast, fate is thought of as being the reason they meet. However, the true reason was because the hopelessly lustful Romeo gatecrashed the gathering fate vs human error romeo juliet answers to see Rosaline and compare her to other women. Because he was so in love
Romeo And Juliet Human Error Essay
with her, he had to see her another time, thus creating the plot device for the two future lovers to meet.It is perfectly natural for both Juliet and Rosaline to be at the feast, because they are Capulet's daughter and niece. In addition, the little accidents that befell Romeo and Juliet are simply coincidences. For example, when Friar Lawrence's message is unable to reach Romeo, it is because the messenger was delayed by a mistaken (but common) encounter with health officials, not because the lightning of fate struck him. However, the real human errors were Romeo's impulsive choices. From killing Tybalt to buying the poison that he would later drink to kill himself, Romeo made all the wrong choices because he acted instead of waiting for a little while. Even though Mercutio and his death acted as the catalyst to Romeo's banishment, it was mainly Romeo's fault for impulsively killing Tybalt as revenge for Mercutio's death. The other huge mistake that Romeo made was to immediately declare that he would "lie with" Juliet, and to kill himself with poison by Juliet's side. If Romeo had waited and mourned properly, instead of instantly committing suicide, he might have lived to see Juliet alive again. Of course, his impetuous character would not let him do this. There were many other human errors, such as Tybalt's violence, Mercutio's troublemaking and Sampson and Gregory's starting fights with the Montagues. For these reasons, I believe that the ending of"Romeo and Juliet" is not the result of fate, but of the numerous mistakes that the characters make. Posted by Selina's English blog at 2:30 AM Email ThisBlogThis!Share to TwitterShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest 1 comment: Vanessa TheriaultJune 3, 2015 at 10:58 AMthis is lovelyReplyDeleteAdd commentLoad more... Newer Post Older Post Home Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom) Romeo+Juliet Followers Blog Archive ▼ 2011 (18) ► October (1) ▼ September (3) Romeo and Juliet: A play about love Sonnet: Goodbye Romeo and Juliet: Fate or human error? ► July (1) ► May (4) ► April (1) ► March (4) ► February (4) About Me Selina's English blog View my complete profile Ethereal template. Powered by Blogger.
Help Suggestions Send Feedback Answers Home All Categories Arts & Humanities Beauty & Style Business & Finance Cars & Transportation Computers & Internet Consumer Electronics Dining Out Education & Reference Entertainment & Music Environment Family & Relationships Food & Drink Games & Recreation Health Home & Garden Local Businesses News & Events Pets Politics & Government Pregnancy & Parenting Science & Mathematics Social Science Society & Culture Sports Travel Yahoo Products International Argentina Australia Brazil Canada France Germany India Indonesia Italy Malaysia Mexico New Zealand Philippines Quebec Singapore Taiwan Hong Kong Spain Thailand UK & Ireland Vietnam Espanol About About Answers Community Guidelines Leaderboard Knowledge Partners Points & Levels Blog Safety Tips Education & Reference Homework Help Next In Romeo and Juliet, are these http://selinalenglish9.blogspot.com/2011/09/romeo-and-juliet-fate-or-human-error.html events fate or human error? 1. Romeo receives news that Juliet is dead. 2. Romeo buys poison. 3. The friar's message does not reach Romeo. 4. Paris and Romeo meet at Juliet's tomb. 5. Romeo kills Paris. 6. Romeo swallows the poison. 7. Juliet stabs herself with Romeo's dagger. 8. Friar Laurence tells the truth to all. 9.... show more 1. Romeo receives news that Juliet is dead. 2. https://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20130525102525AAst88L Romeo buys poison. 3. The friar's message does not reach Romeo. 4. Paris and Romeo meet at Juliet's tomb. 5. Romeo kills Paris. 6. Romeo swallows the poison. 7. Juliet stabs herself with Romeo's dagger. 8. Friar Laurence tells the truth to all. 9. Capulet and Montague end the feud. Follow 4 answers 4 Report Abuse Are you sure you want to delete this answer? Yes No Sorry, something has gone wrong. Trending Now Leo Messi Laverne Cox One Direction Relationship goals Bob Dylan Fantasy Football Stevie Wonder Mortgage Calculator Dating Sites Eniko Parrish Answers Relevance Rating Newest Oldest Best Answer: I'd say fate. Remember in the prologue how it says that the families are doomed and "civil blood makes civil hands unclean." Romeo and Juliet can't escape their destiny. Now, that being said, young, passionate, illogical Romeo is the perfect vehicle to wield the hand of fate. Seriously, all the deaths can be traced back to him. tl;dr The prologue tells how the story ends, making it fate. Source(s): Rachel · 3 years ago 0 Thumbs up 0 Thumbs down Comment Add a comment Submit · just now Asker's rating Report Abuse The whole story is based off fate. For example, when Romeo ki
2008 Romeo and Juliet were not star-crossed, merely young fools. On this topic Minnesota Twins Commit Errors, Strand Players in 5-3 Defeat by Milwaukee Brewers; Twins Will Try to Avoid Series Sweep Tomorrow Afternoon How Can we Get Better Accountability From The Media Switching http://www.bukisa.com/articles/12601_the-choices-of-romeo-and-juliet-it-was-not-fate-but-human-error Methods Romeo and Juliet is a tale about two star-crossed lovers who are not so much control by fate as by their own and others choices. The demise of Romeo and Juliet can be attributed more to their poor choices http://www.123helpme.com/assets/17049.html then to being star-crossed. One way in which poor decisions affect the outcome of Romeo and Juliet is Romeos inability to choose the right choice. Romeos really in love with the idea of love not in love itself. This is apparent human error when he first meets Juliet; he just had his heart broken by another girl. To satisfy “love” he will not do anything in the logical simple way, why didn't he go to ask Capulet to court his daughter? Did he have to sneak under her balcony the first night? Would the families have kept them apart if he had approached them? Romeo needs to fulfill the fairytale he has formed around the word love. Romeo believes that what should happen will happen, fate vs. human he loves Juliet they should get married. That decision alone had a large part in their ends as it forces Juliet to do something to avoid her marriage to Paris. Why was it necessary to marry so soon? It simply wasn't, it was a naïve view of how things work. Romeo killed Tybalt, true it was self defense but due to the choices of others previous to their encounter it was the last straw for the Prince who immediately banish Romeo even if he knew Romeo was a good person. In a perfect world that would not have happened, since it is not the world as Romeo sees it he is now banished. His banishment leads to another innumerable amount of mistakes, such as buying an illegal potion from the apothecary who he coincidental seemed to notice would sell it to him due to his lack of money. It was a very poor choice to go immediately to her tomb to kill himself, it had only been a few days they had known each other and he put no thought into killing himself to be with her? His worst decision was not considering the consequences of his actions before he was facing them. Juliet is also responsible for the outcome of the situation. She was not as directly responsible but she added mistakes of her own to the problem. The same flaw in them both about love being all powerful and instant manife
believe it to be controlled by a person's own actions. In Romeo and Juliet, fate is one of the main themes, described as having power over many of the events in the play. Fate is often called upon, wondered about, and blamed for mishaps. However, where fate is blamed in the play as the ultimate cause for a mishap, there is always an underlying action, or combination of them, on the part of human beings that decides the consequences. Human weakness, the loss of self-control, is always the direct cause of a bad choice or mishap, and not fate itself. One of the most noted instances where fate is blamed for a mishap is when Romeo cries out the he supposedly is fortune's fool. He claims that fate has brought on Mercutio's death, and has lead him to kill Tybalt in revenge. In Act 3, Scene 1 of Romeo and Juliet, Romeo is seen to be upset at Mercutio's death and predicts that the "days black fate on more days doth depend." (III, I, 118) Tybalt then re-enters and Romeo becomes more upset that Tybalt is triumphant with Mercutio being dead (III, I, 121). As Romeo becomes overwhelmed with Mercutio's death and Tybalt's joy over it, he suddenly declares that either he or Tybalt must die with Mercutio (III, I, 128). Tybalt responds predictably and threatens Romeo (III, I, 129). Romeo takes the threat, then fights Tybalt until Tybalt is finally killed. When Tybalt dies, Romeo suddenly comes to grips with what he has done, and, unable to believe that he did this of his own will, cries out that he is fortune's fool (III, I, 135). While many people may say that Romeo's grief caused him to kill Tybalt, this still places no responsibility on fate. Romeo, being a peaceful individual, should have kept as much of his cool as possible when dealing with the situation. Leaving was a choice that Romeo had, and would most likely have spared Tybalt's life and the consequences of his death. Benvolio also had the choice to take Romeo away while he was in despair, and so it was in part Benvolio's choice not to that led to the tragic results. Romeo's comment on black fate is a thought that foreshadows ill events in the future. Since he realizes that these events will take place, he should try to control them as much as is possible by keeping a cool head and not letting his emotions rule him, as is seen to be the case. This would give Romeo control over his future, taking away the element of fate. Capulet is viewed as a man who enjoys control. His decision to have Juliet ma